Cedar Shake Siding Explained: What is It, Pros and Cons

When it comes to adding character and natural beauty to a home’s exterior, cedar shake siding is a timeless choice.

In this guide, we'll explore cedar shake siding, highlighting its advantages and disadvantages. We'll also compare it to shingles and review other low-maintenance alternatives for your home.

What is Cedar Shake Siding?

Cedar shake siding is a kind of siding made from cedar wood. It comes from natural cedar logs that are split by hand or cut into thick pieces called "shakes." It's most commonly used for home exteriors where homeowners want a rustic, natural, or historic look.

Cedar shakes have a more textured and handcrafted look than uniform shingle or panel siding. They feature deep grain patterns and rich shadow lines.

Why Homeowners Choose Cedar Shake Siding

A One-of-a-Kind Look

Each cedar shake is slightly different. The varying textures, widths, and grains give a home more depth and visual interest. It's this natural variation that makes cedar wood siding such a favorite for homeowners looking to boost curb appeal.

Built for More Than One Style

Modern cedar shakes are much more flexible than older versions. You can use them for entire exteriors or smaller accent sections. Whether you're sprucing up a Cape Cod or giving your bungalow a refresh, cedar shake siding fits right in.

Real Depth You Can See

Cedar shakes have a layered surface that creates bold shadow lines. That extra dimension helps break up flat walls and adds warmth that’s hard to achieve with smoother siding options.

You Call the Color Shots

You don't have to stick with the natural cedar look. Many homeowners now experiment with bold stains or even paint, adding personality while still keeping the wood grain visible.

Naturally Resists the Elements

Thanks to its oils, cedar is more rot-resistant than many other woods. It holds up well in moisture-prone areas, especially when installed with proper ventilation.

Long-Lasting With the Right Care

When cared for properly, cedar shake siding can last for decades. It performs especially well in drier climates and provides a durable barrier when regularly sealed and maintained.

Cedar Shake Siding Drawbacks to Keep in Mind

A Bigger Investment Upfront

A significant drawback is the expense. Cedar shake siding is pricier than vinyl or fiber cement due to its genuine wood composition and the individual installation of each shake, increasing labor costs.

High-Maintenance Compared to Alternatives

To keep your siding looking great, you’ll need to clean it, inspect it, and re-stain or seal it every few years. Skip the maintenance, and small issues can become expensive repairs.

Moisture Can Still Be a Problem

Even though cedar is rot-resistant, it’s not waterproof. Without proper care, moisture can sneak in, causing rot, swelling, or warping—especially on shaded areas that dry slowly.

Sunlight Takes a Toll

Cedar naturally fades over time. While some homeowners like the gray weathered look, others see fading as a downside. You’ll need UV protection if you want to keep the original color.

Not Immune to Pests

Cedar does a decent job of repelling bugs, but it's not pest-proof. Termites and carpenter ants can still move in, especially if someone damages the wood or fails to seal it.

Fire Risk in Certain Regions

Cedar is still wood, and untreated shakes can be a fire hazard in dry, wildfire-prone areas. Some treatments can help, but check local building codes before you commit.

Moss and Mildew May Appear

In damp or shady spots, moss and mildew can grow on cedar shakes. It’s mostly an appearance issue, but if ignored, it can lead to moisture damage.

Shakes vs. Shingles: Know the Difference

Cedar shakes and cedar shingles aren’t the same. Shingles are machine-cut and smooth, making them perfect for clean, uniform finishes. Shakes are hand-split, thicker, and rougher – ideal for that natural, rustic style.

You can use both on home exteriors, but shakes bring more texture, while shingles offer a more refined look. Your choice depends on the style you’re going for.

How Long Do Cedar Shakes Last?

With regular upkeep, cedar shake siding can last anywhere from 20 to 40 years, sometimes more. Dry climates and good airflow help it last longer. In humid areas, more care is needed to stop rot or warping.

Caring for Cedar Shakes: Tips That Pay Off

• Clean once a year with a soft brush or low-pressure hose to remove dirt and mildew.
• Stain or seal every 3 to 5 years to protect against moisture and sun damage.
• Inspect for cracks, soft spots, or insect signs annually.
• Cut back plants that are too close to the siding. It keeps moisture and bugs away.

Stay consistent, and your cedar wood siding will stay looking sharp for decades.

Smart Alternatives: Style Without the Stress

Vinyl Cedar Shakes That Mimic Wood Grain

Vinyl cedar shake siding is one of the most popular alternatives. It captures the textured look of real cedar without the constant care.

Vinyl doesn’t rot, warp, or attract insects. It holds its color well and never needs painting or staining. It's also more affordable upfront and over time due to virtually no maintenance costs.

Feldco Shake Siding offers the natural charm of cedar without the maintenance headaches – get your free quote today from a trusted Midwest company!

Engineered Wood That’s Built to Last

LP SmartSide shake siding is made from engineered wood that's specially treated to resist decay, termites, and moisture. It delivers the look of cedar with better impact resistance and longer durability. It's a great middle ground: more natural-looking than vinyl but tougher than traditional wood. And it requires far less maintenance than cedar.

Engineered wood strands create LP SmartSide shakes, and manufacturers treat them to resist moisture and insects. They’re tough, long-lasting, and perfect for harsh Midwest weather.

Feldco installs LP SmartSide shakes in Chicago with professional service and long-term reliability.

Fiber Cement That Holds Up

Fiber cement shakes are made from sand, cement, and cellulose. They're extremely durable, fire-resistant, and low maintenance – great for busy homeowners who want lasting style.